Bonita Smoke Shop
Powered by MaxBlogPress 

Cigar Lighters – WTF?!

One advantage to not being terribly popular, or having sponsors, is I can speak my true opinions without fear offending the wrong people. On that note…

Today’s rant is on cigar lighters, and the absolute lack of quality being sold at premium prices. I can only hope a manufacturer reads this post and tries to contact me. It would be therapeutic for me to be able to tell them their products are a joke…

My first was a Xikar butane dual torch. Six months after owning it, one day I went to refill it, and the bottom literally blew out. Luckily they have a lifetime warranty and I was able to get it replaced at Ed’s shop instantly. I still use the lighter to this day, but I’m still frustrated of how it broke after minimal use. I simply don’t trust it anymore. Xikar – I love the cutting products, but I’m on the fence with your lighters.

Update 11/21/2009)

My faith has been renewed in Xikar lighters. Not from personal experience. I’ve been using my old PB207 blazer for awhile now. I’ve heard multiple people rave about Xikar lighters, and of course, mine is working fine. And like I mentioned before, you can’t argue with the no hassle warranty. Xikar – You win!

My second lighter was a Blue Rhino triple flame. It seemed to be a solid lighter. Within one month, the pole that held the lid close kept falling out. Then shortly afterwards, whenever I’d refill it, the butane would immediately leak out of the bottom. I sent it back under warranty for replacement. That was two months ago, and I have yet to hear back from them. Blue Rhino – An inferior product with shitty customer service. Really… I can’t express my hatred toward you in a blog.
UPDATE 6/21/08
Looks like they got around to sending me a new lighter. It seems to work well. As always, time will tell. I’m not trusting it either way…

My third lighter was a Colibri. It features a dial that allows you to switch between a soft flame, a single torch, and wind proof. It’s a great concept. I had to have it. Within a couple months of ownership, the latch that holds the lid closed literally split in half. It was made of cheap plastic so I wasn’t surprised. This confirms the dozens of Colibri horror stories. Colibri has stated they are improving quality of their cheap, badly designed, made in China, mass produced garbage. I’m calling BS, and won’t be spending my money on their products indefinitely. Colibri – seriously, go screw yourself.

Update – 2-19-2009

Well, it looks like Colibri did indeed go screw themselves. They have closed their doors and are no more. I do feel badly for the jobs lost though. Bummer.

Another update – 11-21-2009

Colibri was bought out by another company, and reopened their doors. They claim better quality control. I’ve heard this before from them, right before they went out of business. I will NEVER buy a Colibri product again. You guys still suck.

My fourth lighter was a Zippo Blu. I figured with Zippo’s reputation of quality and durability, I couldn’t go wrong when they decided to make a torch lighter. The lighter is still making a solid single torch flame, but it won’t stay lit for very long. I should also mention, I only use quality butane, and clean per the company’s instructions. I will be sending it back to Zippo for repair. Zippo – Stick with what you know. Your venture into torch lighters is crap.

My fifth, and latest lighter, is a Blazer PB-207. It’s intended purpose is for soldering, jewelry work, sweating pipes, electronic repair, etc. It can be left on (via a stay on switch) until it runs dry with no damage. I paid $30.00 for it. So far I love it, but time will tell if it can handle excessive use. So far, other people have nothing but good things to say about it. We shall see…

And there you have it, my horrible experiences with cigar lighters. I hope this helps someone out there avoid purchasing the garbage that I have in the past.

Update – 10-22-2009

The blazer is still going strong. I have noticed it doesn’t like cold weather, and it doesn’t perform well in wind. Otherwise, all is well.
Another update – 11-21-2009

Today was a sad say. The blazer finally died. Cleaning and purging didn’t help at all. It just doesn’t flame up consistently anymore. Oh well, we had good times since June 2008. RIP Blazer PB207

This entry was posted on Saturday, June 14th, 2008 at 6:45 am and is filed under Misc, rants, Tips and Info. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

15 Responses to “Cigar Lighters – WTF?!”

Jerry @ The Stogie Review June 14th, 2008 at 8:02 am

Nicely done my brother from another mother!

Personally I think we are on a never ending quest for a reliable lighter. Maybe these lighters aren’t made for those of us who smoke so many cigars every day? I don’t know but its frustrating to have to look for a new lighter every year or sooner.

herhumidor June 14th, 2008 at 3:45 pm

I’ve also had my share of dud lighters. My first one was some no-name butane lighter I bought off Amazon when I first started smoking. It fell apart. Then I decided to splurge on a Xikar triple flame lighter and that one could not stay lit to save it’s life. Finally, I bought a nice French made Dupont X-tend and so far it seems to be performing well.

I like not having sponsors also, because then you can really tell them how you feel.

Totally Not This Guy June 15th, 2008 at 8:58 am

The only thing that sucks more than these lighters is this post! And by extension this blog and the author of said blog.

Do you hear that noise? That’s the incredible sucking power of this of all things to be found on this domain. And several domains that just happen to have similar spelling. And a few guys named Tom that have absolutely nothing to do with this. (So leave ‘em out, dammit!)

Oh and by the way, I’ve had pretty good luck with my Rocky Patel torch. Going on probably 6 months now, and no issues. And the Alec Bradley “Bunsen Burner” lighter seems pretty solid, but I don’t give it heavy enough use to really tell.

But where was I? Did I cover all the sucking? Are you feeling reasonably embarrassed and ashamed yet? Good. Oh dammit, now even this comment sucks. How did you do that?!

Hatefully,
Some guy who totally isn’t Brian.

brianhewitt June 15th, 2008 at 9:02 am

Wow Tom,
Looks like you got some comment hatin’. Wonder what that guy’s problem is? Somebody poo in your wheaties, “totally not this guy”?

The thing that really sucks about butane lighters is that it just doesn’t seem to matter how much money you spend on ‘em they just die prematurely. When next my prefered torch dies, I’m just gonna buy one of those Creme Brulee torches at Bed Bath and Beyond. Though I have heard good things about those Blazers…

Tom June 15th, 2008 at 9:35 am

Guy who totally isn’t Brian-
I appreciate the thought put into this hate message. Really, I do!

Guy who totally is Brian –
I’ll follow up with the ol Blazer in awhile. I’m hoping my lighter ranting days are over. That will allow me to get angry at other stuff.

George June 21st, 2008 at 12:16 pm

Tom –
I offer you the same lighter advice I gave Jerry (and others at http://www.stogieguys.com/2006/12/stogie-guys-friday-sampler-xxii.html)
You will be amazed at the quality and longevity of the single-flame butane torch made by Ronson and available at stores like Wal-Mart for under $3. It also works just fine on cheap Ronson fuel. I’ve had one for over a year and have never had a problem with it, unlike other, far more expensive, lighters I’ve had in the past.

Tom June 21st, 2008 at 3:43 pm

George,
Next time I’m there, I’ll be sure to keep an eye out for em. For that price, I’ve got nothing to lose. Thanks for the info.

HerHumidor – So far the new torch is doing well. Time will tell!

Rocky June 29th, 2008 at 12:21 am

Tom,

I agree with George on this. I misplaced a Xikar lighter and saw these Ronson lighters in Walmart for $2.94 ea. I picked up three of them figuring they wouldn’t last long, but long enough to get a “good” replacement. Here I am a year and a half later still using the first of three, and I’ve only used the cheap Ronson butane to fill it. It works well, lasts a long time between fill ups and you can’t beat the price! What more can you ask for? I also recommended this lighter to Jerry at the Stogie Review.

Khyber April 21st, 2009 at 10:40 pm

Where did you buy your Blazer PB-207 for $30? Thanks.

Tom April 22nd, 2009 at 5:12 pm

I can’t recall now, but I have seen them at Heartfelt Industries for 30-40 recently. Click the link on my site and check em out.

Wayne February 15th, 2010 at 4:35 pm

I’ve settled on stick matches, the longer the better. Siglo makes good ones. Some light a strip of cedar from the box, but like some cigar practices, this seems more of the ritual that also adds to cigar enjoyment.

I’ve usually had to use one for toasting and another for lighting, but as I get better, one match does the trick.

After one has paid for a great smoke like a My Father, Padron 1926, or Casa Magna,wooden matches work just great, are inexpensive, and somehow feel “right” in a world of Spanish cedar, tobacco, fire and smoke.

Thanks for an enjoyable site with down-to-earth guys doing what the rest of us do and offering their opinions like good cigar buddies are wont to do.

Michael July 31st, 2010 at 10:39 pm

Zippo just redesigned the insides of the Zippo Blu and they work beautifully now! I visit Bradford, PA (home of Zippo) often and just returned mine to their shop because I was having the same issues. They repaired it and it is now just a sweet and smooth lighter, the way a Zippo should be!! Highly recommended!

Tom August 1st, 2010 at 9:50 pm

Michael,

I may send mind back and see what happens. Thanks for the info.

Teal Curtains November 6th, 2010 at 2:36 am

You have given me great points for my new article and i am going to use that.

Bjarte Ryland June 20th, 2012 at 9:48 pm

Hi, and greetings from Norway.
I absolutely agree, dear Sir!
I got a tri-flame Nibo, fell apart after five months. I got a single flame Firebird, it kinda work, but it’s unreliable.
This little charmer:
http://www.lightinthebox.com/Jet-1300-C-Butane-Lighter-with-Clear-Tank_p76624.html
works like a clock. I bought it over a year ago, and still going strong. One minus: Not wind proof.

Leave a Reply